Characterizing Fluorescence Properties of Turn-on RNA Aptamers.

Fluorescent RNA aptamers are tools for studying RNA localization and interactions in vivo. The photophysical properties of these in vitro selected RNAs should be characterized prior to cellular imaging experiments. Here, we describe the process of determining the fluorophore affinity, fluorescence enhancement, and fluorescence lifetime(s) of the Mango-III fluorescence turn-on aptamer. Parameters determined through these protocols will aid in establishing conditions for live-cell imaging.

The bacterial yjdF riboswitch regulates translation through its tRNA-like fold.

Unlike most riboswitches, which have one cognate effector, the bacterial yjdF riboswitch binds to diverse azaaromatic compounds, only a subset of which cause it to activate translation. We examined the yjdF aptamer domain by small-angle X-ray scattering and found that in the presence of activating ligands, the RNA adopts an overall shape similar to that of tRNA. Sequence analyses suggested that the yjdF aptamer is a homolog of tRNALys, and that two of the conserved loops of the riboswitch are equivalent to the D-loop and T-loop of tRNA, associating to form an elbow-like tertiary interaction. Chemical probing indicated that this association is promoted by activating ligands such as chelerythrine and harmine. In its native mRNA context, activator ligands stabilize the tRNA-like fold of the yjdF aptamer, outcompeting the attenuated state in which its T-loop base pairs to the Shine-Dalgarno element of the mRNA. Moreover, we demonstrate that the liganded aptamer itself activates translation, as authentic tRNAs, when grafted into mRNA, can potently activate translation. Taken together, our data demonstrate the ability of tRNA to function as a small-molecule responsive cis regulatory element.

An uncommon [K+(Mg2+)2] metal ion triad imparts stability and selectivity to the Guanidine-I riboswitch.

The widespread ykkC-I riboswitch class exemplifies divergent riboswitch evolution. To analyze how natural selection has diversified its versatile RNA fold, we determined the X-ray crystal structure of the Burkholderia sp. TJI49 ykkC-I subtype-1 (Guanidine-I) riboswitch aptamer domain. Differing from the previously reported structures of orthologs from Dickeya dadantii and Sulfobacillus acidophilus, our Burkholderia structure reveals a chelated K+ ion adjacent to two Mg2+ ions in the guanidine-binding pocket. Thermal melting analysis shows that K+ chelation, which induces localized conformational changes in the binding pocket, improves guanidinium-RNA interactions. Analysis of ribosome structures suggests that the [K+(Mg2+)2] ion triad is uncommon. It is, however, reminiscent of metal ion clusters found in the active sites of ribozymes and DNA polymerases. Previous structural characterization of ykkC-I subtype-2 RNAs, which bind the effector ligands ppGpp and PRPP, indicate that in those paralogs, an adenine responsible for K+ chelation in the Burkholderia Guanidine-I riboswitch is replaced by a pyrimidine. This mutation results in a water molecule and Mg2+ ion binding in place of the K+ ion. Thus, our structural analysis demonstrates how ion and solvent chelation tune divergent ligand specificity and affinity among ykkC-I riboswitches.

Fluorogenic aptamers resolve the flexibility of RNA junctions using orientation-dependent FRET.

To further understand the transcriptome, new tools capable of measuring folding, interactions, and localization of RNA are needed. Although Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) is an angle- and distance-dependent phenomenon, the majority of FRET measurements have been used to report distances, by assuming rotationally averaged donor-acceptor pairs. Angle-dependent FRET measurements have proven challenging for nucleic acids due to the difficulties in incorporating fluorophores rigidly into local substructures in a biocompatible manner. Fluorescence turn-on RNA aptamers are genetically encodable tags that appear to rigidly confine their cognate fluorophores, and thus have the potential to report angular-resolved FRET. Here, we use the fluorescent aptamers Broccoli and Mango-III as donor and acceptor, respectively, to measure the angular dependence of FRET. Joining the two fluorescent aptamers by a helix of variable length allowed systematic rotation of the acceptor fluorophore relative to the donor. FRET oscillated in a sinusoidal manner as a function of helix length, consistent with simulated data generated from models of oriented fluorophores separated by an inflexible helix. Analysis of the orientation dependence of FRET allowed us to demonstrate structural rigidification of the NiCo riboswitch upon transition metal-ion binding. This application of fluorescence turn-on aptamers opens the way to improved structural interpretation of ensemble and single-molecule FRET measurements of RNA.

Structure-Guided Engineering of the Homodimeric Mango-IV Fluorescence Turn-on Aptamer Yields an RNA FRET Pair.

Fluorescent RNA aptamers have been used in cells as biosensor reporters and tags for tracking transcripts. Recently, combined SELEX and microfluidic fluorescence sorting yielded three aptamers that activate fluorescence of TO1-Biotin: Mango-II, Mango-III, and Mango-IV. Of these, Mango-IV was best at imaging RNAs in both fixed and live mammalian cells. To understand how Mango-IV achieves activity in cells, we determined its crystal structure complexed with TO1-Biotin. The structure reveals a domain-swapped homodimer with two independent G-quadruplex fluorophore binding pockets. Structure-based analyses indicate that the Mango-IV core has relaxed fluorophore specificity, and a tendency to reorganize binding pocket residues. These molecular properties may endow it with robustness in the cellular milieu. Based on the domain-swapped structure, heterodimers between Mango-IV and the fluorescent aptamer iSpinach, joined by Watson-Crick base pairing, were constructed. These exhibited FRET between their respective aptamer-activated fluorophores, advancing fluorescent aptamer technology toward multi-color, RNA-based imaging of RNA coexpression and colocalization.

Co-crystal structure of the iMango-III fluorescent RNA aptamer using an X-ray free-electron laser.

Turn-on aptamers are in vitro-selected RNAs that bind to conditionally fluorescent small molecules and enhance their fluorescence. Upon binding TO1-biotin, the iMango-III aptamer achieves the largest fluorescence enhancement reported for turn-on aptamers (over 5000-fold). This aptamer was generated by structure-guided engineering and functional reselection of the parental aptamer Mango-III. Structures of both Mango-III and iMango-III have previously been determined by conventional cryocrystallography using synchrotron X-radiation. Using an X-ray free-electron laser (XFEL), the room-temperature iMango-III-TO1-biotin co-crystal structure has now been determined at 3.0 Šresolution. This structural model, which was refined against a data set of ∼1300 diffraction images (each from a single crystal), is largely consistent with the structures determined from single-crystal data sets collected at 100 K. This constitutes a technical benchmark on the way to XFEL pump-probe experiments on fluorescent RNA-small molecule complexes.

Tracking RNA with light: selection, structure, and design of fluorescence turn-on RNA aptamers.

Fluorescence turn-on aptamers, in vitro evolved RNA molecules that bind conditional fluorophores and activate their fluorescence, have emerged as RNA counterparts of the fluorescent proteins. Turn-on aptamers have been selected to bind diverse fluorophores, and they achieve varying degrees of specificity and affinity. These RNA-fluorophore complexes, many of which exceed the brightness of green fluorescent protein and their variants, can be used as tags for visualizing RNA localization and transport in live cells. Structure determination of several fluorescent RNAs revealed that they have diverse, unrelated overall architectures. As most of these RNAs activate the fluorescence of their ligands by restraining their photoexcited states into a planar conformation, their fluorophore binding sites have in common a planar arrangement of several nucleobases, most commonly a G-quartet. Nonetheless, each turn-on aptamer has developed idiosyncratic structural solutions to achieve specificity and efficient fluorescence turn-on. The combined structural diversity of fluorophores and turn-on RNA aptamers has already produced combinations that cover the visual spectrum. Further molecular evolution and structure-guided engineering is likely to produce fluorescent tags custom-tailored to specific applications.

Structure and functional reselection of the Mango-III fluorogenic RNA aptamer.

Several turn-on RNA aptamers that activate small-molecule fluorophores have been selected in vitro. Among these, the ~30 nucleotide Mango-III is notable because it binds the thiazole orange derivative TO1-Biotin with high affinity and fluoresces brightly (quantum yield 0.55). Uniquely among related aptamers, Mango-III exhibits biphasic thermal melting, characteristic of molecules with tertiary structure. We report crystal structures of TO1-Biotin complexes of Mango-III, a structure-guided mutant Mango-III(A10U), and a functionally reselected mutant iMango-III. The structures reveal a globular architecture arising from an unprecedented pseudoknot-like connectivity between a G-quadruplex and an embedded non-canonical duplex. The fluorophore is restrained into a planar conformation by the G-quadruplex, a lone, long-range trans Watson-Crick pair (whose A10U mutation increases quantum yield to 0.66), and a pyrimidine perpendicular to the nucleobase planes of those motifs. The improved iMango-III and Mango-III(A10U) fluoresce ~50% brighter than enhanced green fluorescent protein, making them suitable tags for live cell RNA visualization.

Crystal Structures of the Mango-II RNA Aptamer Reveal Heterogeneous Fluorophore Binding and Guide Engineering of Variants with Improved Selectivity and Brightness.

Several RNA aptamers that bind small molecules and enhance their fluorescence have been successfully used to tag and track RNAs in vivo, but these genetically encodable tags have not yet achieved single-fluorophore resolution. Recently, Mango-II, an RNA that binds TO1-Biotin with ∼1 nM affinity and enhances its fluorescence by >1500-fold, was isolated by fluorescence selection from the pool that yielded the original RNA Mango. We determined the crystal structures of Mango-II in complex with two fluorophores, TO1-Biotin and TO3-Biotin, and found that despite their high affinity, the ligands adopt multiple distinct conformations, indicative of a binding pocket with modest stereoselectivity. Mutational analysis of the binding site led to Mango-II(A22U), which retains high affinity for TO1-Biotin but now discriminates >5-fold against TO3-biotin. Moreover, fluorescence enhancement of TO1-Biotin increases by 18%, while that of TO3-Biotin decreases by 25%. Crystallographic, spectroscopic, and analogue studies show that the A22U mutation improves conformational homogeneity and shape complementarity of the fluorophore-RNA interface. Our work demonstrates that even after extensive functional selection, aptamer RNAs can be further improved through structure-guided engineering.

Structural Principles of Fluorescent RNA Aptamers.

Several aptamer RNAs have been selected in vitro that bind to otherwise weakly fluorescent small molecules and enhance their fluorescence several thousand-fold. By genetically tagging cellular RNAs of interest with these aptamers and soaking cells in their cell-permeable cognate small-molecule fluorophores, it is possible to use them to study RNA localization and trafficking. These aptamers have also been fused to metabolite-binding RNAs to generate fluorescent biosensors. The 3D structures of three unrelated fluorogenic RNAs have been determined, and reveal a shared reliance on base quadruples (tetrads) to constrain the photo-excited chromophore. The structural diversity of fluorogenic RNAs and the chemical diversity of potential fluorophores to be activated are likely to yield a variety of future fluorogenic RNA tags that are optimized for different applications in RNA imaging and in the design of fluorescent RNA biosensors.

Structural basis for high-affinity fluorophore binding and activation by RNA Mango.

Genetically encoded fluorescent protein tags have revolutionized proteome studies, whereas the lack of intrinsically fluorescent RNAs has hindered transcriptome exploration. Among several RNA-fluorophore complexes that potentially address this problem, RNA Mango has an exceptionally high affinity for its thiazole orange (TO)-derived fluorophore, TO1-Biotin (Kd ∼3 nM), and, in complex with related ligands, it is one of the most redshifted fluorescent macromolecular tags known. To elucidate how this small aptamer exhibits such properties, which make it well suited for studying low-copy cellular RNAs, we determined its 1.7-Å-resolution co-crystal structure. Unexpectedly, the entire ligand, including TO, biotin and the linker connecting them, abuts one of the near-planar faces of the three-tiered G-quadruplex. The two heterocycles of TO are held in place by two loop adenines and form a 45° angle with respect to each other. Minimizing this angle would increase quantum yield and further improve this tool for in vivo RNA visualization.

Divalent ion competition reveals reorganization of an RNA ion atmosphere upon folding.

Although RNA interactions with K+ and Mg2+ have been studied extensively, much less is known about the third most abundant cation in bacterial cells, putrescine2+, and how RNA folding might be influenced by the three ions in combination. In a new approach, we have observed the competition between Mg2+ and putrescine2+ (in a background of K+) with native, partially unfolded and highly extended conformations of an adenine riboswitch aptamer. With the native state, putrescine2+ is a weak competitor when the ratio of the excess Mg2+ (which neutralizes phosphate charge) to RNA is very low, but becomes much more effective at replacing Mg2+ as the excess Mg2+ in the RNA ion atmosphere increases. Putrescine2+ is even more effective in competing Mg2+ from the extended conformation, independent of the Mg2+ excess. To account for these and other results, we propose that both ions closely approach the surface of RNA secondary structure, but the completely folded RNA tertiary structure develops small pockets of very negative electrostatic potential that are more accessible to the compact charge of Mg2+. The sensitivity of RNA folding to the combination of Mg2+ and putrescine2+ found in vivo depends on the architectures of both the unfolded and native conformations.

A divalent cation-dependent variant of the glmS ribozyme with stringent Ca2+ selectivity co-opts a preexisting nonspecific metal ion-binding site.

Ribozymes use divalent cations for structural stabilization, as catalytic cofactors, or both. Because of the prominent role of Ca2+ in intracellular signaling, engineered ribozymes with stringent Ca2+ selectivity would be important in biotechnology. The wild-type glmS ribozyme (glmSWT) requires glucosamine-6-phosphate (GlcN6P) as a catalytic cofactor. Previously, a glmS ribozyme variant with three adenosine mutations (glmSAAA) was identified, which dispenses with GlcN6P and instead uses, with little selectivity, divalent cations as cofactors for site-specific RNA cleavage. We now report a Ca2+-specific ribozyme (glmSCa) evolved from glmSAAA that is >10,000 times more active in Ca2+ than Mg2+, is inactive in even 100 mM Mg2+, and is not responsive to GlcN6P. This stringent selectivity, reminiscent of the protein nuclease from Staphylococcus, allows rapid and selective ribozyme inactivation using a Ca2+ chelator such as EGTA. Because glmSCa functions in physiologically relevant Ca2+ concentrations, it can form the basis for intracellular sensors that couple Ca2+ levels to RNA cleavage. Biochemical analysis of glmSCa reveals that it has co-opted for selective Ca2+ binding a nonspecific cation-binding site responsible for structural stabilization in glmSWT and glmSAAA Fine-tuning of the selectivity of the cation site allows repurposing of this preexisting molecular feature.

Comparison of interactions of diamine and Mg²âº with RNA tertiary structures: similar versus differential effects on the stabilities of diverse RNA folds.

Cations play a large role in stabilizing the native state of RNA in vivo. In addition to Mg²âº, putrescine²âº is an abundant divalent cation in bacterial cells, but its effect on the folding of RNA tertiary structure has not been widely explored. In this study, we look at how the stabilities of four structured RNAs, each with a different degree of dependence on K⁺ and Mg²âº, are affected by putrescine²âº relative to Mg²âº. Through the use of thermal melts, we observe that (i) at a given concentration, putrescine²âº is less effective than Mg²âº at stabilizing RNA, (ii) the stability imparted to RNA by various diamines is a function of charge density (average separation distance between charges) as well as the flexibility of the counterion, and (iii) when Mg²âº is already present in a buffer, further addition of putrescine²âº may either destabilize or stabilize RNA structure, depending on whether the native RNA does or does not chelate Mg²âº ion, respectively. At ion concentrations likely to be found in vivo, the effect of putrescine²âº on the free energy of folding of an RNA tertiary structure is probably quite small compared to that of Mg²âº, but the ability of mixed Mg²âº/putrescine²âº environments to (in effect) discriminate between different RNA architectures suggests that, in some cells, the evolution of functional RNA structures may have been influenced by the presence of putrescine²âº.